2786 New York 80, Fort Plain, NY 13339

Evermore Glen is a rare pairing: a cottage with a story you won't find anywhere else, set on over 55 acres of diverse, usable land. The home began its life as the local toll booth in 1880 and has been thoughtfully reimagined into an intimate, character-rich retreat, the kind of place that feels like it was always meant to be here, tucked into this hillside along a sparkling stream.

Inside, every detail has soul. Original wide-plank floors carry the patina of nearly 150 years. A fireplace that...